Best Dutch Oven for Soups and Braises

A Dutch oven is a sturdy, lidded pot, typically made from enameled cast iron, that retains heat exceptionally well for browning, simmering soups, and slow braising in the oven. For most home cooks, a 5.5- to 6-quart round enameled Dutch oven is the most versatile size, with enough room for a whole chicken, a generous batch of soup, or a pot roast.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through one of my links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting my blog!

My Top Picks

I have cooked in all four of these. If you only want the answer and not the reasoning, buy the Lodge and spend the difference on groceries. It is genuinely close to pots that cost five times as much.

Around 80 dollars, and it braises and simmers within a hair of the expensive French pots. The enamel is not quite as refined and it is heavy, about 14 pounds full of nothing, but you will not panic when someone puts it in the dishwasher. This is the one I recommend to everybody who is buying their first one.

The pot everything else gets compared to. You are paying for the sand colored interior that does not stain the way white enamel does, a lifetime warranty that actually replaces the pot, and about three pounds less weight than the Lodge, which you feel every time you lift a full one out of a hot oven. Worth it if you will use it weekly for twenty years.

The dark matte enamel inside grips and browns meat better than the smooth pale interiors, so you get a deeper fond before the liquid goes in. The little spikes under the lid drip condensation back over the food while it simmers. The tradeoff is that you cannot see the fond as easily against a dark surface.

If you are cooking for one or two, the big pots are a workout for no reason. This size still handles a pot of beans, a small chicken, a frittata, or soup for three, and it fits in a normal cabinet instead of living on the stove forever.

What Actually Matters When You Shop

Dutch ovens are one of those things where the specs sound fussy and only about four of them change how dinner turns out. These are the four.

• Size: A 5.5 to 6 quart does about ninety percent of jobs, including a whole chicken, soup for six, or a pot roast. Go up to 7.25 quarts only if you genuinely cook for a crowd most weekends, because the bigger pots are heavy enough that you will start avoiding them.
• Round beats oval: Round sits properly over a burner so the heat comes up evenly. Oval hangs off the edges and scorches in a ring. Only buy oval if you are specifically roasting long cuts and whole birds more often than you make soup.
• Enameled versus bare cast iron: Enameled needs no seasoning, handles tomatoes and wine without tasting metallic, and wipes clean. Bare cast iron is cheaper and sears harder, but acidic food strips the seasoning and you have to maintain it. For soup and braises, get enameled.
• A light interior: This sounds like a nitpick and it is not. The browned bits stuck to the bottom are the flavor of the whole dish, and on a pale surface you can see exactly when they go from deep brown to burnt. On dark enamel you are guessing.
• An oven-safe knob: Check the rating before you buy. Some brands ship a plastic or phenolic knob that caps out around 375 to 400 degrees, which is a problem for bread and long braises. Stainless knobs are fine at any oven temperature, and on most pots you can buy one separately for a few dollars.

What to Skip

• Anything under 3 quarts. There is not enough room for liquid to move around a piece of meat, so it steams instead of braising.
• Thin aluminum pots sold as Dutch ovens. The entire point is heavy walls that hold steady heat. A light pot swings temperature every time you add cold ingredients.
• 8 quarts and up, unless you batch cook constantly. Empty, it is already a heavy lift, and a half batch of soup in a huge pot reduces too fast.

How to Not Wreck It

• No metal utensils on the enamel. A metal spoon scraping the bottom chips it, and once the enamel chips the cast iron underneath starts to rust. Wood or silicone only.
• Let it cool before it hits water. Hot enamel plus cold water is how pots crack. Give it twenty minutes on the stove first, which is roughly how long dinner takes anyway.
• Never preheat it empty on high. Enamel is glass and it does not love a shock. Put the oil in first and bring it up on medium.

Dutch Oven FAQs

What size Dutch oven is most useful?

Between 5.5 and 6 quarts. That range holds a whole chicken, a pot roast with vegetables, or soup for about six people, and it is still light enough to move around when it is full. If you are mostly cooking for one or two, a 3.5 quart makes more sense and you will reach for it more often.

Is an expensive Dutch oven worth it?

Honestly, only sometimes. The premium pots have better enamel that resists chipping and staining, they weigh less, and the warranty will replace the pot if something goes wrong years later. But a good mid-price enameled pot cooks nearly identically. If this is your first one, buy the cheaper one and find out how often you actually use it.

Can you make soup in a Dutch oven?

It is the best pot in the house for it. You can brown your onions and meat right in the pot, add your liquid, and move the whole thing to the oven if the recipe wants that, all without dirtying another pan. The heavy walls also mean a simmer stays a simmer instead of creeping up to a boil.

Can a Dutch oven go in the oven with the lid on?

Yes, that is exactly what it is built for, as long as the knob is rated for your temperature. Check the knob rating first, because some are only good to about 400 degrees. A stainless replacement knob is a cheap fix if yours is the plastic kind.

Why did my enamel stain brown?

That is normal and it is not damage, especially on white interiors. Simmer a little water with baking soda in it for ten minutes, or use a paste of baking soda and a soft sponge. Do not go at it with steel wool, which will scratch the enamel and make the staining worse next time.

Best Dutch Oven for Soups and Braises

If you are buying one pot, make it the 6-quart Lodge and then go use it the same week, because the fastest way to get your money back out of it is soup. Start with my cozy soup recipes, and if you would rather walk away from dinner entirely, my fall slow cooker recipes cover the hands-off end of the same job.

More You'll Love